© 2026 The Rev. Seth Olson
This sermon was preached on the Twenty-Fifth Sunday after Pentecost at the Episcopal Church of the Holy Apostles in Hoover, AL. To view a video of it, please click here.
Holy God, let my words be your words, and when my words are not your words, let your people be cunning enough to know the same. Amen.
In the mid-1960s, in the small coastal town of Coos Bay, Oregon, a short, thirteen-year-old boy failed to make it off the bench of his junior high school’s football team. Soon afterward, he noticed some members of the cross-country team running by the football field. He thought, “What a mundane sport!”
As the year wore on, however, his team moved into offseason conditioning. After a few days of running mile after mile, the boy found that he excelled at long distances. He had a choice: continue warming the bench in a more popular sport—and bury his God-given gift—or try his talent in a sport he thought was boring.
If you lived through the running boom of the 1970s, or have run competitively since then, you probably can guess his identity. Instead of hiding his gifts away, this teenager ran down the path less traveled. He developed into one of the most iconic runners in American history. His name? Steve Prefontaine.
At one time, he held every U.S. outdoor track record from 2,000 to 10,000 meters. Even today, his legendary status holds among runners everywhere. Just mention his name to a distance runner and a smile will cross their face.
This did not have to be the case. “Pre,” as he was affectionately called, could have kept pursuing football or another sport. He could have quit sports altogether. Even once he gained success in running, he did not have to keep going. However, as he put it, “To give anything less than your best is to sacrifice the gift.” While this is certainly an all-or-nothing way of seeing things, it brings us to the question today’s Gospel puts before us: What will we do with the gifts God imparts to us?
Three servants were given a large sum of money, each according to their ability. Two straightaway went out and began using what had been entrusted to them. Both doubled the initial investment and joyfully came to meet their master. The third? Well, the third faced the same options that Prefontaine faced: use what he had been given or bury it. This great runner might seem to have little in common with the third servant, but they nonetheless faced the same decision. And, to tell you the truth, we face that choice too. Do we use the gifts given to us or not?
Now, let me pull back the curtain for a moment. I struggle with this passage. Every time I read how the master treats the timid third servant, I cringe. I can identify with that servant. As I imagine being given a large sum of money—or talent—and being expected to double it, a wave of anxiety washes over me. Burying the money just to be done with it sounds like a relief, if the expectation is to produce a big return on investment. There have even been times when I don’t just want to hide the money—I want to find a place to hide myself, so that I might find some respite.
Traditional Christian scholarship equates the powerful master in this parable to God. But, is God really this harsh? Do we dare compare God to an absentee, slave-holding, ill-tempered, hot-headed, tyrannical master? Let’s back up for a moment.
In the first part of the story, the master does resemble Our God—the Divine One of self-giving love that we so often encounter in Holy Scripture. The master generously entrusts the servants with abundance, allows them to choose how those resources are utilized, and welcomes the first two faithful servants with joy. This sounds like God the generous, free-will imparting, ever-embracing Father. But things go off the rails when the third servant, paralyzed by fear, returns with his dirty talent. I wonder how much the servant’s fear shaped the relationship before that conversation ever began.
Because the text is clear, the master gave generously without asking for a certain return on investment. He does not say they must double the money. Yet the third servant acts as though failure would be unbearable. Before he ever picks up a shovel, he has decided what kind of master he serves: someone to fear. But doesn’t the ending seem to confirm everything the servant feared? Why is he thrown into the darkness, where there is weeping and gnashing of teeth? It almost looks like giving a toy to a child, then getting upset that the child is more excited to play with the box than the gift itself.
And yet, there is one more wrinkle in this story. This parable has historically been linked to God’s righteous judgment—something we will hear more about next week in parable of the sheep and the goats. However, the life of Jesus points out that God’s judgment can never be separated from God’s love. We must practice caution before believing every action of this master is a perfect picture of God. At some point, the parables and language itself fall short. Regardless, we still hear the question this story asks: What happens when fear keeps us from participating in the life entrusted to us?
If the third servant had tried his hardest but failed mightily, what would the master have done? The parable does not tell us. But when I look at Jesus—at the disciples who stumble, misunderstand, deny him, and are still called back into relationship—I have reason to hope that failure would not have been the end of the story. Failure is not what the master reprimands here. The servant never risks using what he has been given at all.
So, I hate to break it to you, but this story is not about success, and neither is life in Christ. Life in Christ is not about winning, reaching a certain status, being in the perfect relationship, having the right job, or living in the best house. Life in Christ is about God gifting us with talent, and regardless of how scary it is, how many times we fail, or how uncomfortable it makes us, we are to wisely but generously share that talent with others—not so we can double our net worth, but so that we can, with God’s help, reveal the Reign of Christ, already at work in this world.
And sharing our gifts does not mean exhausting ourselves. Burying the talent is not code for rest. Neither is asking for help or acknowledging that what we can offer today may be different from what we could offer ten years ago. Giving our best begins with offering what we actually have, rather than punishing ourselves for what we don’t.
Here in this community of Holy Apostles, we can be tempted to measure our life together by numbers: attendance, pledges, budgets, or how many people attend an event. Those things matter. They help us care for the life entrusted to us. But they cannot tell the whole story. A meal delivered to someone grieving, a backpack filled for a hungry child, a welcome offered to someone unsure if they will ever belong—these are gifts being put to use.
The moral of the story is not that we must succeed or God will throw us out. The message is that we are called to participate in Christ’s Reign here on earth by sharing abundantly what we have received in abundance. And if you’re wondering why, it is so that with God and each other, we can make real the dream God has for this world, but we can’t do that by hiding our talent in the ground.
So, it’s up to us: Will we let fear rule in our hearts—afraid of trying that thing we dream of doing because we don’t know how it will go? Or will we see that even in challenging times, God’s abundance remains, such that with gratitude we invest our talents in the world around us? What does this look like?
Perhaps that begins with making the phone call we have been putting off. Offering to help with a ministry before we feel completely qualified. Sharing an idea without knowing whether anyone will embrace it. The gift does not have to be spectacular to be worth sharing. It only has to leave our hands and enter the life of another.
God continues to give us talent. God entrusts us with so much, and even when we fail, God still lovingly embraces us. Will we sacrifice the gift, or will we use what God has given us? If we know that even if we falter, God waits with open arms, what audacious, apostolic actions will we do together with God’s help? Amen.

